Comments on: Classical Guitar Fingernail Basics

By: Bob

Bob — Fri, 12 Aug 2011 04:48:51 +0000

Great comments. In addition to things mentioned, above, I push the cuticle back with one of those “thing-a-ma-gigs” that the ladies use. I also apply Hoofmaker now and then. As for length, I turn my right-hand palm facing me, then, with the thumb and index finger of my left hand, I squeeze the end of each finger against the finger nail of my right hand. I keep my nails filed to a point where I can just see a sliver of the nail over the top of my fingers. Hope that you were able to follow this explanation (it would be much easier to show you).

This approach helps to take the guessing out of how much to file. For longer nails, you may want to see more than a sliver, etc.

By: Christopher Davis

Christopher Davis — Fri, 21 Jan 2011 04:36:08 +0000

You should not do the Presti Technique, Michael. Those videos are more of a curiosity and a learning thing rather than practice advice.

By: Michael S. Jackson

Michael S. Jackson — Thu, 13 Jan 2011 17:40:09 +0000

I don’t know if anyone will read my comment but I’m going to leave one anyway. I really liked the videos re: Ida Presti technique. However, I simply cannot play this way. If you notice her right forarm is almost perpendicular to the floor. To try to do this, I have to raqise my right shoulder extremely high and actually lean my body to the left (port). I wonder if this has to do with shoulder width? When I get into this contortion, I feel as if it would be easier if my shoulders were not so far apart (narrow, as they are with most women). I don’t know.
But I did like the advice about relaxing and not pulling up on the string, stroke arc, etc.
One thing I will try to experiment with is my left hand thumb in relation to the fretting fingertips. She said it sould be behind the middle or maybe even patially behind the left hand ring finger. What a difference from how my hand naturally goes! My thumb naturally goes to a point between my index and middle fingers. But when I play it usually ends up directly behind my index finger. I’ll try moving my thumb toward the guitar body (as opposed to the nut direction) and see what happens. Maybe this will cure my hand pain when I play; I’ve had this pain for 4 years now and can’t play more than about 30 seconds without severe pain in the base of my thumb. Also, I will try to get my thumb to roll over onto its side, as she said, but this is not natural for me.
As for nails, if you do the Ida technique, it would make a huge difference on how the nails are shaped. I like a slight ramp with my nails a bit higher on the release point on the right side (as the hand is held outstrectched), with the “a” finger slightly more toward the middle. I noticed others posting here have said the same thing and that makes me feel good about my experimentation conclusions.
Thanks for the ideas!

By: Christopher Davis

Christopher Davis — Thu, 26 Aug 2010 11:50:53 +0000

If you have hooked nails you’ll need to experiment more with your nail shape. That said, they’re going to be have to be very hooked to make a huge difference. Try doing more of a “ramp” (straight line) than a curve.

By: Matt D.

Matt D. — Wed, 25 Aug 2010 01:35:34 +0000

It is beyond me how anyone–even from centuries ago, can play classical guitar
with absolutely no nails. That is to say, with any speed and anything but tiny little
pencil sized fingers. Can someone explain?

Also what is a remedy for hooked nails–that is, hooked at the tip when viewed
straight on down the finger. Again, when I hold my right hand out in front of me
with the palm facing my face, and bend my fingers down so I am looking “down”
them, the middle of the tips of only the i and m finger have a slight (not huge)
“beak”. Something like the beak of an eagle for instance. I believe this may
be slightly hindering my speed. What to do?

By: Robert

Robert — Sat, 18 Jul 2009 08:33:31 +0000

Why is fingernail length important for playing classical guitar? Was it always like this?

#####
No, it wasn’t always like this. We do use nails now, but early guitarists did not use nails. Even Taregga didn’t use nails. But most modern players today do. It’s a personal choice as far as I’m concerned — though using nails does make thing easier.

By: Max

Max — Sat, 11 Jul 2009 18:16:41 +0000

Good posting. The problems I’ve seen many face are both the issues of catching the string with a “hook” nail, or the nail that protrudes too far off of the finger that produces what I call “the pause.” This is a small interruption of the note that happens when the string falls between the flesh and the nail as it is plucked (producing a rather unappealing “click” sound with each note). It’s very slight, and even some professional guitarists do this and don’t even realize it. But once a serious student is aware of it, they will spend however long it takes to get rid of it.

********

I have always subscribed to the method that my first guitar teacher taught me. When she was studying in Columbia as a child, she learned that fingernails are indeed individual to each player; no one disputes this. However, this individuality is no reason to stop the lesson of nail shaping (as MANY do). In fact, it IS the lesson. Because of the individuality of each players fingers, the lesson of nail shaping is:

The tips of your fingers are to be the template for how your nails are shaped.

Think about it; by shaping your nails the same as your fingertips you are instantly creating a “oneness” between the two which, as many will tell you, allows for the ideal sound. Quite simply, the best way to achieve this is by imitating the very finger the nail grow from.

When one reads the countless instructional books on shaping nails they often times make reference to a rather defined angle they call a “ramp” that is suppose to allow the nail to easily guide the string off, producing a great tone. They are correct in this, but the method and degree of creating said ramp is usually misleading. There really is no pronounced ramp per se, but rather an uninterrupted union between the finger and its’ nail.

Look at your fingertip. It is not perfectly round or symmetrical. There are tiny curves within the outline of the tip. It is these curves and angles that is crucial to
the shape of your nail. (Incidentally, these same curves are also the “ramp” that all those books are talking about. If you file your nails to create a “ramp” and produce a good tone with it now, it’s only because your ramp just happens to be the same angle as your finger tip. It is not an isolated technique! This is one in the same.) I never knew how many tiny curves and angles my fingertip had until I looked at it under a magnifying glass. The larger the magnifying power, the more I saw what I needed to do with my fingernail shape. Try this as a starting point and you will be on your way to producing a warm tone others only dream of.

By: Bobber

Bobber — Wed, 08 Jul 2009 16:27:21 +0000

A very good presentation here Chris. I agree that nails are very much an individual thing. The term “nail bed” is new to me but what you say is right on. The shape of the finger tips as well as the size of the nail bed will have a tremendous effect on the length of the nail. People frequently comment on my sound (generally good comments I mean) and are amazed at my short nails but my nail bed is quite long and my finger tips are more blunt than most so short nails go a long way with me.

By: GuitarVlog

GuitarVlog — Fri, 03 Jul 2009 02:03:51 +0000

It’s good that you mentioned the matter of the nail bed. Players will sometimes try to file their nails to the length suggested by a photo of another player’s hand and will end-up with nails that are too long.

Only my index and middle RH fingernails have ramps that extend along 75% of the edge. That is is because both nails are relatively flat. The ring finger nail is more evenly shaped on both sides because it is curved. The pinky fingernail is evenly shaped and a bit longer for flamenco rasgueos.

For hygiene, I use a toothbrush and soap to clean underneath the nails.

By: Jamie C

Jamie C — Fri, 03 Jul 2009 00:13:18 +0000

I agree, a great and informative post. As for what to shape with, I’ve found that 3M’s Tri-M-Ite sandpaper works best for me. A full sheet will last you a long time, and it yields great results for both shaping and buffing (I use it mostly for buffing with a crystal file for shaping). You can get it at on most guitar websites (GSP, stringsbymail).

I’m actually undergoing a bit of a nail crisis myself right now, and have been for quite some time. I have a growth (wart) at the cuticle of my M finger, and it’s doing terrible things to my nail. Since the nail grows at the cuticle, the wart is cutting off a lot of nutrients for healthy nails to grow, so it’s very brittle and has developed a nasty hook on the right side. It’s also actually growing faster on the right side, so when looking at the nail dead on, instead of a nice arch, it points to the right, which gives me pretty awful tone if I don’t get it right. Because of the way it grows, fake nails won’t stick either…really sucks!

I’m currently working with a dermatologist to get that fixed, but it’s a slow process…then I have to wait for the nail to grow out completely from the cuticle…ugh! Until then, anybody have any tips? It’s mostly the hook that’s killing me.

Okay, done venting…

#######
Have you tried gluing a ping-pong ball piece underneath the nail? That could be a good temp. solution. -CD